Most people are familiar with the term "market bubble." In fact, over the past two decades, investors have experienced ﬁrsthand two historically signiﬁcant market bubbles – the real estate market bubble that occurred in the 2000s and the tech-stock bubble that occurred in the late 1990s.
Technically, a market bubble is an economic event in which the prices of speciﬁc assets rise dramatically and increase beyond their fundamental value. In general, bubbles are viewed as outbursts of irrationality — self-generating and self-sustaining waves of optimism that drive up asset prices and cause investments to be misallocated. There is no general consensus among ﬁnance academics or practitioners as to what causes an asset bubble to form or what sustains the overvalued prices over the life of the bubble. However, one commonly discussed theory related to the continuation of a bubble is "The Greater Fool Theory".
The Greater Fool Theory is the idea that, during a market bubble, one can make money by buying overvalued assets and selling them for a proﬁt later, because it will always be possible to ﬁnd someone who is willing to pay a higher price. An investor who subscribes to the Greater Fool Theory will buy potentially overvalued assets without any regard for their fundamental value. This speculative approach is predicated on the belief that you can make money by gambling on future asset prices and that you will always be able to ﬁnd a "greater fool" who will be willing to pay more than you did. Unfortunately, when the bubble eventually bursts (which it always does), there is a large sell-oﬀ that causes a rapid decline in the asset values. During the sell-oﬀ, you can lose a great deal of money if you are the one left holding the asset and cannot ﬁnd a buyer.
Speciﬁcally with regard to the stock market, the Greater Fool Theory becomes relevant when the price of a stock goes up so much that it is being driven by the expectation that buyers for the stock can always be found, not by the intrinsic value (cash ﬂows) of the company. Under this assumption, any price (no matter how high) can be justiﬁed since another buyer presumably exists who is willing to pay an even higher price.
So as an advisor, should you ever try to implement a greater fool strategy? How do you recognize a client that wants to play the greater fool game? What should you do if your client wants to buy an overpriced stock?
Should you ever try to implement a greater fool strategy?
There is abundant evidence that, with respect to investors, greater fools actually exist. However, this is a very risky strategy that is not recommended for long-term investors. Successfully implementing a greater fool strategy is labor intensive and time intensive. One must pay an excessive amount of attention to markets, because price trends can reverse in minutes. Most clients (and advisors) do not have the time and resources to do that. The greater fool strategy usually is not a feasible or sustainable one for investors who do not have the speculation and market trend expertise of full-time day traders.
Moreover, while speculation based on a belief in The Greater Fool Theory has the potential to make money, there is signiﬁcant risk that your client(s) could turn out to be the greater fool. When the bubble bursts and the music stops, you do not want your client left standing without a chair.
How do you recognize a client who wants to play the greater fool game?
Greater fools generally are impatient investors who are attracted to stocks that are popular or "hot". They are not interested in the steady, consistent returns, or value stocks. When markets begin to twitch, these types of clients will want to move on to the next "hot" stock.
What should you do if your client wants to buy an overpriced stock?
It has been well-documented by academics and ﬁnance professionals that stock returns are what we call "mean-reverting" (which is to say that stock prices move around but they eventually move back to their mean/average price). When the price of a "hot" stock rises too far above its average, the price will eventually decline. In these situations, it can be useful to remind your client that no one has a crystal ball to predict exactly when a market bubble will burst or when a particular stock's mean-reversion will happen. Let them know that a greater fool strategy is a form of speculation and that they do not want to be holding the bag when there are no more greater fools left to sell to at a higher price.
- The Greater Fool Theory is a very risky, speculative strategy that is not recommended for long-term investors.
- While speculation based on a belief in The Greater Fool Theory has the potential to make money, there is a big risk that the greater fool could turn out to be your client.
- Watch out for impatient clients who are only focused on investing in "hot" stocks. Try to educate them on market fundaments, like mean-reversion, and the importance of a long-term focus.
Abreu, D. & Brunnermeier, M.K. (2003). "Bubbles and Crashes." Econometrica, 71 (1), pp. 173-204.
The views and opinions expressed herein are those of the author, who is not affiliated with Hartford Funds. The information contained herein should not be construed as investment advice or a recommendation of any product or service nor should it be relied upon to, replace the advice of an investor's own professional legal, tax and financial advisors. Hartford Funds Distributors, LLC.
Hartford Funds is not responsible for, and does not validate, any information, opinions, assertions, or statements expressed within these articles, or the identity or credentials of the individuals communicating through the site. Some of the articles may contain links to information created and maintained by other, unaffiliated organizations and individuals. Hartford Funds does not control, cannot guarantee, and is not responsible for the completeness, accuracy, timeliness, or the continued availability or existence of this outside information or the information presented herein. This material is intended for use by financial professionals or in conjunction with the advice of a financial professional.